05 Aug 2018 15:35:18
If United sign Fred dalot and a cb and get rid of pogba and martial have we had a good window .
Players like pogba and martial leaving wanting out of a club like United.
Not a good sign.
05 Aug 2018 15:45:23
jred.
I would hope that Jones and Smalling would be first out of the door.
05 Aug 2018 15:48:30
Martial i will lose no sleep over. Jose or otherwise, his time at utd was never going to amount to anything.
Pogba - gutted of he leaves/ genuinely wants to leave us.
05 Aug 2018 16:03:08
No that would be an awful window i think.
05 Aug 2018 16:06:06
Ken
If we got a cm a cb and full back that Jose wanted
And got rid of 2 players he doesn't want .
I think there are signs all is not well to be honest.
05 Aug 2018 16:24:43
If we were able to replace them it shouldn't be too much of a problem. I think its been quite obvious the board have tried to penny pinch this summer. Sanchez will be like a new signing, Fred looks decent. If we can clear out a few more and bring a couple in I don't think its that bad. As long as replacements are in. I don't see the fuss over martial. And if pogba doesn't want to be here he can go to. can't the point in keeping anyone who doesn't want to be here. We've lost bigger players than those too. But seems some people too eager to panic.
05 Aug 2018 16:37:47
I agree mort.
05 Aug 2018 16:37:55
Mort ed has said time and again we are willing to spend the cash.
05 Aug 2018 16:47:37
What if Fred is pogba replacement .
1 in 1 out.
05 Aug 2018 17:08:34
I doubt it. We only have matic, Herrera and alas Fellaini. Even with pogba that's just 4. We were light last season. If pogba leaves he'd have to be replaced. Andy p probably replaces Carrick in the squad.
05 Aug 2018 17:08:43
If pog wants out n the club can sell they should we've seen in the past how disruptive it can get when jose falls out with people. Personally if pog goes i'm happy with fred i don't think kroos is the answer n it could be a case of trying to move him on if jose leaves n the next manager doesn't want him.
05 Aug 2018 17:22:30
Mort
Matic Herrer fellaini fred mc Tom perry.
Jose wanted fellaini and rid of pog.
05 Aug 2018 17:52:13
McTom and Andy P will probably make 2 dozen appearances between them. Fellaini is useless in midfield and is better further forward. Ed has said the board want pogba out as much as Jose does. We'd still be light. Or are you just being argumentative again.
05 Aug 2018 18:19:33
Mort
Jose has said time and again he wants fellaini.
We know he wants rid of pogba.
That leaves us with matic, mc Tom, pereira, fellaini, Herrera and Fred.
6 players for the 2 positions in a 4231.
05 Aug 2018 18:52:30
And we know the board want rid of pogba. Who says it will be 2 in midfield. Might be 3. So you'd be happy to go into the season with 2 rookies, a player untried in England, matic who was over used, Herrera and a midfielder who's no good in midfield.
05 Aug 2018 19:40:38
Mort
No but I'm not the manager .
We also know the board have backed the manager.
You say fellaini is no good but obviously the manager thinks he is .
This is Jose team.
05 Aug 2018 19:49:35
Again mort why do the board want rid of pogba?
06 Aug 2018 09:37:21
Ask Ed2.
{Ed002's Note - People seem to be struggling with the concept that players are simply transient and clubs will look to improve each season - so players come and go.}
07 Aug 2018 11:21:19
Nothing to do with the club, entirely of their own making and personality. Martial can’t hack that the manager constantly wants more and adds pressure when he doesn’t put the work in. The least we’d expect playing at a top club like Utd. Maybe he wants to cruise in Italy or Spain? I don’t see a huge queue forming of big clubs for Martial knowing that he is available?
I’ll admit if Pogba leaves I’ll be very disappointed as think he could be a star for us, but don’t see the Martial thing at all.