10 Nov 2026 21:28:50
Interesting fact, for the upcoming internationals round we have 17 Academy players picked for their respective nations.
11 of them for various England grade levels.
2 for Scotland.
2 for RoI.
1 N. Ireland.
1 for Australia (no, not Skippy!)
Good luck to them all for the coming days.
There is a part of the club functioning well!!
Manchester United Banter 4
Use our rumours form to send us manchester united transfer rumours.
18 Nov 2026 00:24:01
In order to view all of today's posts, you may have to visit our Manchester United Discussion pages and our Manchester United match posts pages.
10 Nov 2026 19:15:20
Doesn't it say a lot that both berrada and wilcox need to speak to SJR? We all know Wilcox has massively screwed up, so why isn't it Berrada, as CEO that is responsible for firing him. From a corporate hierarchy perspective it feels a bit needy that berrada is taking Wilcox to talk to SJR about changing the manager.
If SJR is as controlling as it suggests, then it also suggests how much Wilcox has influence with SJR, as well as how weak Berrada and his position is.
What do you think?
10 Nov 2026 20:34:54
This meeting of the three of them has been arranged for some time.
The international break is an ideal opportunity to meet for discussions on all club matters.
The meeting was not arranged specifically for discussions regarding the future of Carrick.
10 Nov 2026 20:36:41
Perfectly normal in my experience NR.
A ceo reports to the board and shareholders. A deciding of this magnitude cannot and will not be done unilateraly in any business of this scale.
10 Nov 2026 20:38:48
It worries me more that SJR is still backing Wilcox and Berrada. This is sadly a common thread where managers look after each other at the expense of those at the work face regardless that the mess is their doing.
These clowns whilst clearly successful businessmen in their chosen field, are not suited to the running of a sport team where sacking the manager every 5 minutes is not the answer.
As I said in a previous post, don't hold your breath gents. This f*** up is a long time away from being fixed. There are going to be many more casualties before they luck upon the right decision and rub themselves silly in celebration.
10 Nov 2026 23:19:00
Agreed that the CEO reports to the board and shareholders, but Berrada is CEO and SJR is the shareholder. It doesn't feel right that Wilcox has so much representation at that level. The guy was recruited from Southampton, and promoted internally into the role - on a basis that no external party can understand.
From the outside I have no idea why Wilcox is that important to the club.
11 Nov 2026 00:26:10
Wilcox has to go. He has made to many expensive errors that have cost success in the pitch.
Manager will change, but we would be fools to think the buck stops there. Carrick was his last chance, and the summer was underwhelming, although we will never know if the budget was limited- spending it all on 1 spot in the team was lunacy. Back 4 issues were predictable. Unable to sell rashford
Hopefully SJR sees sense this week.
11 Nov 2026 02:12:17
The director of football going and meeting is absolutely appropriate. I think the problem is that it is wholly inappropriate that wilcox os our director of football!
11 Nov 2026 09:56:49
Would like to think Berrada might have questions to answer about the dodgy dealings that went on down the road. still don't know when they actually stopped.
11 Nov 2026 11:09:56
Can't afford to pay the tea lady, can afford to fly the lads out to Monaco for a meeting.
11 Nov 2026 14:02:24
We still have a tea lady we don't have 3. That makes sense.
10 Nov 2026 14:56:49
Doesn’t matter who the manager is some of this lot are not coachable
How many managers have to come before they start getting rid of the dross that the manager has to play
The likes of dalot Maguire Martinez Maz, mount Ugarte Zirkzee
You could name about 10 players or more that simply are not good enough regardless of the manager
11 Nov 2026 17:22:14
Bolger that's far too extreme. We have some good players. Of your list Dalot, Maguire, Ugarte are clearly not part of a successful future. The others aren't as obvious. Our issue is that we're not just weak in some positions, we are playing those who wouldn't start for any other EPL side.
And our tactics - for whatever they are - this year has in many respects put more emphasis on those players because we've reverted to a low block side.
10 Nov 2026 13:57:45
Ed001 i am not 100% sure but i think you had reservations abour Pochetino back then. You said something like he is good but he has not that extra to succedd at the top.
I am of this opinion too. Athough his USA team is a really good team. what's your opinion on him?
{Ed001's Note - he is weak on discipline, which sees his teams fold when under pressure. He is not a top class manager. A big step up from Carrick and maybe the answer to get you to a place where you can go get that kind of manager though. He is certainly a steady hand.}
10 Nov 2026 14:30:21
Thanks Ed001. He would not be my first choice but i understand he is a solid midterm solution.
{Ed001's Note - yeah that's how I see it too.}
10 Nov 2026 15:18:15
We have had multiple solutions and mid-term solutions that weren't the solution. How about supporting a manager so they learn and get it right rather than dumping them as soon as things get tough. We need a defence and a new DOF or give the manager the power to recruit as wel.
Wilcox sais he likes to interfere and maybe that the problem right there. Hopefully the meeting in Monaco is to get rid of the DOF rather than the manger.
10 Nov 2026 18:21:28
Spot on Arty.
10 Nov 2026 20:14:41
Good shout arty.
11 Nov 2026 01:43:48
I will go early and say that Poch does not fill me with hope. I don't have any reason for that other than a gut feeling that it is just not right. For that matter neither do Howe or Naglesman.
Sadly I feel that we are in for a long disappointing ride and will have more managers over the next decade than we will titles.
I would rather we went for Keane and had some entertainment for a while because it sure as s### ain't happening on the park!
10 Nov 2026 21:14:34
That's my thinking on Poch too, Ed001. He's not an elite level manager, but we're not an elite level club. It's better to bring in a solid manager who keeps things simple and gets the club on track for more consistent CL football, than bring in someone like Amorim who won't have players capable of doing what he wants them to.
{Ed001's Note - exactly. Amorim might well go on to be a great manager, but he clearly wasn't right for the position you were in at the time. Poch can work with what you have and get it working, it should be fairly well suited to him.}
11 Nov 2026 07:12:38
It does worry me a bit that he finished bottom half with Kane and Son in his team and couldn't win a one horse race in France.
09 Nov 2026 09:32:15
Live chat once again exposed some of our fans to ahow they are just like the players they despise.
Storming off when losing like spoilt kids.
'I'm not watching anymore'
'Im sick if this'
Just acting like the players they don't like and call out.
Supporters who support when they want can't be critical of players that play when they want, imo your cut from the same cloth as the players.
Fickle unreliable and not worth having.
If you can't support when it's tough you can't expect players to play for you when it gets tough.
09 Nov 2026 10:31:12
Sad I didn't join the chat. Too early here. Seems like I missed out on some good entertainment.
09 Nov 2026 11:05:47
Booing Dalit as he was subbed was so classy I thought.
09 Nov 2026 11:06:56
Ok ken so fans can't be angry?
09 Nov 2026 11:58:08
What a load of nonsense TW. Everyone's different and not everyone has the same tolerance level.
You should've seen the Streford End yesterday. There were a lot of disgruntled fans who have had enough of these players and owners, and they showed it.
It's an emotional game! That's why we spend so much time watching and talking about it.
09 Nov 2026 11:58:10
The analogy doesn't work. We're not being paid to be fans.
09 Nov 2026 12:58:26
Nor do most pay to be fans either. The analogy is sound.
Fans are flakey. Players are flakey. Neither are worse than the other.
Fans don't pay the players so its none of their business what they earn.
No issue with voicing frustration no issue with being frustrated but don't moan about players giving up when you give up as a fan because your just as unrelieable just as flakey and give up very easily.
09 Nov 2026 12:59:11
2 toms all players are different and react differently to adversity just like the fans.
09 Nov 2026 14:31:38
Is that the end of the lesson, Reverend Ken?
09 Nov 2026 14:56:28
Just stating the obvious fizz.
Fans who walk out on the team or give up watching are just as bad as the players and imo have no right to critisise the players manager or anybody else because they are just as flaky.
When the going gets though they would rather watch a grand prix or the likes.
Ive no issue with fans giving up ar walking iut as long a they don't critisise any club employee for doing the same. They are kindred spirits one in the same.
09 Nov 2026 15:08:38
The fans do pay the players. They do pay the owners. They do pay the board. They do pay the employees. The fans have more power than they give themselves credit for.
09 Nov 2026 15:14:40
No they don't pay the players board or anybody else.
Match day revenue wouldn't pay the players weekly payroll db what land are you living in?
Matchday going fans pay more towards the club than most and some fans don't pay 1 penny towards the club overheads don't be talking rubbish.
09 Nov 2026 15:35:52
2 screens ken, 2 screens, technology eh?
09 Nov 2026 15:52:19
I was paying $600yr + $120yr here in the US for 2 subscriptions that enabled me to watch all EPL games + another $120 to watch European football. I cancelled the $600 one. Why would I want to pay that much just to endure a continual stream of stress and disappointment? I'm too old for it and it's not good for my health.
The folks who spent £650-£1200 on season tickets are not so lucky. They can just not show up. They can walk out early, but if they cancel their tickets (which I'm not sure they can do in midseason), they're done. Someone else will take their seat. Such is their reward.
As far as I'm concerned they've paid their money and they're entitled to show their displeasure, frustration and distaste for our owners any way they want, as long as it's legal. Let's face it their loyalty is being abused. There's no way a club like ours, with its revenues, should be anywhere near the drop zone, even with Michael Carrick as manager.
09 Nov 2026 20:55:30
I think that's an incredibly weak technical argument. Nobody seriously thinks a supporter buys a match ticket and that exact £50 then gets transferred into a player's wage packet. The supporter pays Manchester United, and the club pays its employees, including the players, out of its overall finances.
Manchester United generated £160.3m in matchday revenue in 2024/25, with total revenue of £666.5m. That's hardly an insignificant contribution.
Supporters attending matches are therefore generating revenue for the very organisation responsible for paying the players. Trying to claim they have no financial contribution towards players' wages because the money isn't directly ring-fenced for salaries is just splitting hairs. By that logic you could make the same argument about virtually every individual source of club revenue.
09 Nov 2026 21:41:43
Yeah but they're being paid 6 figure salaries, per week, to at least try and do the basics.
And you're saying fans can't get a bit emotional when we sit 18th.
10 Nov 2026 04:47:56
I said the fans. Not the match day going fans.
You will never understand what I mean Ken, too indoctrinated into their world, so not wasting my time.
10 Nov 2026 07:37:52
2 toms everybody is entitled to be frustrated but storming off or not showing up because we are not playing well and winning is childish imo.
The club is not finished despite what the over emtional supporters post on here. That's hperbole in the extreme.
10 Nov 2026 08:22:33
Your opinion is important to you, Ken. Not always necessarily to others.
10 Nov 2026 17:46:32
Its just my opinion Fizz. Its holds no importance for me really.

09 Nov 2026 07:39:02
{Ed's Note - The fox has posted a new article entitled, Manchester United After the SJR Investment
09 Nov 2026 06:54:59
Why are Carrick and team doing what looks like almost a lap of honour after beating Roma and scraping a draw with Villa? It looks cynical, gives supporters the chance to chant Carricks name but it really has no place in where we are.
The club is in a big a mess as I have seen since 1973, they seem clueless, divided, indecisive, lacking leadership. There is absolutely no rationale to keep Carrick after today, for the clubs future he has to go. That defence is not being coached or drilled anywhere near premier league level, it’s a shambles. The word a few days ago is they think it’s the same as SAF in 1989, yet he had shown what he could do at Aberdeen.
It wouldn’t surprise me if the club, just sit there, think Carrick has support of fans singing his name, without realising few will think he is good enough. With Carrick we are in a relegation battle, a manager who thought the first half against Roma was good and Dalot is doing ok.
Utter incompetence if Carrick stays beyond today.
09 Nov 2026 08:04:48
Crystal Palace are sacking their manager, they are 1 place and 1 point below us, yet we seem content to carry on .that tells u all u need to know. Carrick raising his finger, the fans applauding the players and singing his name, berrada and Wilcox jumping up and down.
We are 18th with 8 points from 30. It's embarassing. Serious question? ' The club keep saying they don't want to sack him and want him to turn it around, to what exactly? 12th? The board and manger literally have us believing that staying up is now a successful season. wtf.
09 Nov 2026 08:46:26
Absolutely appalling. Sick of watching this dross.
We got lucky, very lucky. Mbuemo could/should have been called offside almost directly in front of the keeper. Dorgu's equaliser was enabled by Lammens attacking their 'keeper. Yes, lucky.
09 Nov 2026 09:23:11
We were not lucky and were better team yesterday imo.
Shambolic defending and goal keeping aside.
Why would mbuemo be called offside?
Yes he was obstructing the keeper but he was inside there was a defender behind him.
They were lucky yoro had a brain fart and lammens was half sleep and that dalot was at least 50% responsible for 3 goals.
Carrick should not be in charge for the next game imo.
09 Nov 2026 09:36:33
I don't think it's necessarily about the fans backing Carrick. I think it's more about the fans wanting to make it clear that they blame the leadership above him.
All game the fans were protesting against Berrada and Wilcox while audibly supporting Carrick. The media, the pundits, the commentators and everyone watching at home are picking up on that.
We've also seen the fans turn on the players. What links the players and the leadership is that both have outlasted several managers. The fans won't put up with the merry-go-round any more, so they're going after the players and the people at the top instead.
So when they inevitably sack Carrick and stay up in their ivory towers, they'll be going directly against what the fans want. Yes, some fans want both gone, and I think most of them know Carrick isn't good enough. But this is more about defying the people making the decisions. At least in the eyes of the media, sacking him will look like another blunder.
09 Nov 2026 09:58:01
Ken I just can't get my head around Dalot surely there's someone else who can play that position? They can't be worse than Dalot, it's impossible. Nice lad I'm sure and try's hard apparently but he is atrocious.
09 Nov 2026 10:18:53
He has been here for next post of 10 years Tim.
One poster will claim every manager plays him so he can't be that bad.
Well he can be that bad. He has been part of oa variety of bad back 4s and is a constent it proves how bad he is rather than proving he is best we have.
This is he worst run of form like martinez he costs us goals nearly every game.
He was never good but now he is a complete liability in his current form.
09 Nov 2026 10:51:30
Totally agree Ken, it makes a mockery of the team. No doubt he'll start at anfield too. Let's get it right he's not the only poor performer to be be so bad for so long and yet continue to start is mind boggling.
Carrick was also singing his praises after the game, I get he can't destroy him but come on there's no point gaslighting us as we have eyes to see it for ourselves.
09 Nov 2026 11:44:25
Hopefully Dorgu will be fit enough to do 90 minutes at Anfield because he looked really strong when he came on. Yoro also showed that he's perhaps not quite ready to play CB in the Premier League just yet, although he's done a decent job at RB. So, a back four of Yoro – De Ligt – Maguire – Dorgu, whilst not quite the AC Milan defence of the 80s, is probably the best we can realistically hope for given the options available.
I wasn't particularly keen on the booing of Dalot, to be honest, but I do think it reinforces the argument for taking him out of the starting line-up for the next game or two.
09 Nov 2026 11:59:05
There was a player deeper than Mbuemo when the goal went in.
09 Nov 2026 12:46:01
I must have missed that RWWD.
09 Nov 2026 15:10:21
Thankfully the linesman didn't miss it fizz.
It would have been disallowed otherwise as he was in keepers eye line.
09 Nov 2026 16:03:25
Fizz, Mbuemo wasn't in an offside position. Check it out. There's a defender behind him. Lammens certainly blocked the goalie but he didn't hold him down or back. Goalie was weak.
09 Nov 2026 22:33:50
The way everyone here feels about Dalot is how I feel about amad.
10 Nov 2026 07:39:44
The winger with Hardly any goals and assists for over a year banjoe? 🤣.
08 Nov 2026 23:00:46
I just watched the highlights. It looked like overall we by far the more threatening team. 25 shots v 8. However some of the shots were low % and scorned passing to players in better positions.
The weakness is clearly in the defense for which the club is solely responsible. But, praising Dalot, after he gave away the penalty, was beaten for the first goal, and almost conceded another when he was outpaced by Goretzka, is just nuts.
Clearly Lammens is in a bad mental place since his error at the World Cup , and maybe he should be benched for a while. The second goal in particular was indefensible. Never mind putting it out for a corner, which would have been the easy safe option, but that was not a hard shot at a difficult height. It should have been caught.
08 Nov 2026 23:07:32
Lammens def feeling fragile but I would keep playing him to give him confidence if poss. The problem is he is getting such little protection from the defence.
I don't get the hate for Dalot. For sure he is not playing well but he is not the only one. Putting him on the left is unfair as he is right footed and it's not his natural position but he doesn't complain and plays. He hasn't played well in his natural right back position either but like the whole team he is suffering from a lack of defensive coaching.
I would love Carrick to stay and succeed but if he can't coach the players defensively we need someone who can. The team can't keep getting out of jail game after game.
09 Nov 2026 00:06:04
I think Lammens needs dropping for a few games. Mainly just to protect his progression whilst he is in a bad patch.
SAF did it with De Gea a couple of times when he made high profile errors, and he bounced back to be one of our greatest. Darlow is a very competent keeper and probably deserves a few games.
09 Nov 2026 00:08:45
We are very much IN jail. See EPL table for reference.
09 Nov 2026 02:03:22
The best way to protect Lammens is defend better.
09 Nov 2026 04:00:50
I have said it before and I shall say it again. For the money they are paid and analysis available to teams every player should be able to use both feet proficiently at this level. Sure favour one over the other perhaps but should be able to play on either side of the park in their chosen area of the park.
09 Nov 2026 10:52:42
Lammens is our best form of attack. Fox in the box! It's his fault Carrick is still here today.
08 Nov 2026 22:18:02
Poch now bookies fave tonight. Seems it may be happening.
08 Nov 2026 22:26:30
Isn't he under contract with USA? therefore compensation due so no chance that happens.
08 Nov 2026 22:27:56
Which bookies? Still Eddie Howe with skybet.
08 Nov 2026 21:47:41
Even more embarassing is the fact that palace who are just below us are sacking their manager for poor performances and failure to meet expectations. They are 1 point behind us, meanwhile we are seemingly happy to carry on cos we might win a game sometime this year.