13 Mar 2023 17:51:01
Honest question, do you all believe that United should appeal the Case red card?

While in SLOW MOTION it does look a red, however there is context in it at full speed, the spin on the pass etc. Couple in the fact that the consistency between games (Che v Lei where Felix was fouled much worse) it shocking. Andre Mariner did NOT feel the need to send of the Lei player, however said that Case should go from the VAR booth?

It is tough because if you just appeal based on the challenge, you probably lose the appeal. However, factor in the stuff stated above, and maybe one has a case?

I would be interested in hearing other's thoughts.

1.) 13 Mar 2023
13 Mar 2023 17:57:31
Forget it and move on.

2.) 13 Mar 2023
13 Mar 2023 18:18:01
He dived in and left the ground with his studs up. That decision never get overturned in a million years. Move on and find a win to win without him.

3.) 13 Mar 2023
13 Mar 2023 19:13:05
We do need to move on…. BUT (haha)

I’m not even sure it’s a foul!
He got the ball and hurt the man after
Just like that lad who got the ball but chopped down garnacho with a scissor challenge, which wasn’t given as a foul and rightly so because he got the ball first.

Mariner in the VAR, who was it who sent off cas against palace? oh yeah that’s right, mariner again, on the pitch that time
Funny how he set up the clip for taylor on a freeze frame AFTER cas had already won the challenge, giving a one sided view of the incident

All refs are crap, but he’s next level
He also was VAR for Chelsea v Leicester and he didn’t say anything about the shocking challenge from pereira after like 5 minutes

But we need to move on ?.

4.) 13 Mar 2023
13 Mar 2023 19:22:05
It's a foul, he's unlucky as his foot spun and slid over the top of the ball, but if you go in off the ground studs up then you risk that happening.

Never in a million years will that be overturned and you just risk antagonising the FA by appealing that.

Draw a line under it and move on.

5.) 13 Mar 2023
13 Mar 2023 20:11:47
I am with Shappy. They are not going to overturn a VAR decision, it would just create chaos, they are more likely to add games. Move on.

6.) 13 Mar 2023
13 Mar 2023 23:42:21
It was a crap decision and one that went against us. There’ll be one that goes for us in next few weeks too though.

7.) 14 Mar 2023
14 Mar 2023 09:10:13
Honest answer; NO.

8.) 14 Mar 2023
14 Mar 2023 09:43:58
I've seen Casemiro tackle a few times like that this season.
I think it's the fact that his boot slides over the ball after making contact with it. It then catches the leg of the opponent.
You could that there was no maliciousness in the tackle whatsoever.