20 Mar 2018 08:41:09
Well it’s been a bit feisty on here hasn’t it? I love the debate and discussion but not everything has to be black and white. Just because you want Jose to stay doesn’t mean you agree with how he has treated Shaw. Just because you want Jose sacked doesn’t mean he hasn’t made a lot of progress. This constant black and white “which camp are you in†is getting boring.
Ken, I’ve decided not to comment on your posts any more, the jred / ken show has been getting tiresome; I see a comment from jred and I know there will be a reply from you and it feels like there is an AJH / ken show developing which I want no part of, it really can’t be much fun for everyone else.
Continually stating your opinion over and over again doesn’t change that it is just your opinion, and judging from the likes / dislikes there are enough people to disagree with you without me having to join in.
Ed, can we put this discussion to bed for a while with a poll? Do you want Jose as United Manager next season. Yes or No.
{Ed033's Note -
Jose Manager Poll
20 Mar 2018 09:13:51
That poll is as evenly split at my time of voting as the fans are around the country.
20 Mar 2018 09:22:03
AJH - agree with everything you say about the postings.
The only thing I would change is the poll question, or add an additional question:
Do you think José is getting the best out of the players we have?
Bloody hell, José is a controversial subject, we can't even agree on a poll question lol.
20 Mar 2018 09:22:25
Tony,
That is why I have taken a step back a bit, I know if I post that the same people reply with the same point they already made 10 times, with buzzwords like 'red tinted glasses' being used over and over.
I don't really get why there are different camps, we are all supposed to support the same team and want the same thing at the end of the day. I know people are upset we got knocked out of the CL the way we did and that is fuelling a lot of the posts but I don't know anybody who thought we were going to win it anyway, we are 4 or 5 players away from being anywhere close.
20 Mar 2018 09:23:11
Ajh
It a good shout that and a fair point.
20 Mar 2018 09:36:36
You guys also have to factor in the occasional Liverpool fan voting for José to stay ;-)
20 Mar 2018 11:10:04
couldnt agree more GDS2.
20 Mar 2018 11:15:14
I can't vote, its a difficult question.
Im 100% not happy with the style of play. (manager)
Im 100% not happy with the effort of the overpaid players.
So ideally a load of deadwood would leave and the team will start playing better next season. Who the manager would be is any ones guess and a call I can't make.
20 Mar 2018 11:16:05
Fair point ajh it should be noted its not all one way traffic. I think that's fair to say.
20 Mar 2018 11:51:12
The only reason i'd vote for mou to stay is because of lack of a better suitor. Keyword for me here is better, not potential.
20 Mar 2018 10:05:55
I don’t think José should be sacked at this point, but he does need to at least recognise the failings in his approach and try to adapt. At the moment he looks like he’s hell bent on alienating himself from everyone rather than just accepting that he’s fallible.
20 Mar 2018 10:12:57
Tony, I wrote a similar post the other day which was turned into an article. I find I'm on the fence about Jose, although tilting toward feeling he might have to leave sooner rather than later.
I think a better poll would be are you happy with how Jose has the team playing? I expect we would see a far more United front in that poll.